Beyond Dionysiaques: Florent Schmitt’s Other Works for Concert Band

Florent Schmitt: Complete Compositions for Wind Ensemble (Corelia)The Dionysiaques by Florent Schmitt, composed exactly a century ago, is a blockbuster work for concert band that just gets more and more popular with each passing year.

I’ve blogged before about how this piece has become a staple of the wind band repertoire – particularly in Japan and Europe, but with more performances happening in the United States as well.

But surely the composer of a band masterpiece such as this must have written other works for wind ensemble, right?

Yes … but not extensively. It turns out that the full extent of Schmitt’s band music comprises just a half-dozen works totaling less than an hour’s worth of music between them.

And none are nearly as famous or oft-performed as Dionysiaques.

In fact, until quite recently, most of Schmitt’s other wind band compositions weren’t even available in recorded performances.

Thankfully, that’s been rectified now with the release of a recording containing all of Schmitt’s wind ensemble music on one CD.  Issued on the Corelia label in 2008 — on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of Schmitt’s death — this recording features L’Orchestre d’Harmonie de la Région Centre conducted by Philippe Ferro.

Philippe Ferro

Philippe Ferro

The ensemble is a group comprising amateur and semi-professional instrumentalists in addition to professional musicians.  It’s a welcome addition to the Schmitt discography because it contains a good deal of repertoire that is otherwise unavailable.

One of the more intriguing pieces is Sélamlik, Op. 48, No. 1, inspired by the Turkish ceremonial guard units assigned to the Sultan in Constantinople, and that Schmitt witnessed on parade when visiting the Ottoman Empire in the early 1900s.

Schmitt did a masterful job in capturing the guard’s combination of “pomp and savagery” in his composition, which was completed in 1904 and first performed in 1909 by the Garde Republicaine Band in Paris.

Unlike Dionysiaques, which takes the listener through a variety of highly contrasting moods, Sélamlik conjures up an atmosphere of raucous celebration nearly continuously throughout its entire 5-minute duration. You can sample a live performance of this music on YouTube, performed by the Philharmonic Winds conducted by Seow Yibin.  The Corelia recording of this music has also been uploaded.

Florent Schmitt Selamlik

Florent Schmitt Selamlik score

The front cover and first page of Florent Schmitt’s score to Selamlik, edited by Felix Hauswirth. (Robert Martin Edition, Paris, 2013)

The second half of Schmitt’s Opus 48 is his March for the 163rd Infantry Regiment, which he composed in 1916. This is a longer piece of music and contains somewhat more contrasts and moods within the score.

Invencia Piano Duo

Invencia Piano Duo (Andrey Kasparov & Oksana Lutsyshyn)

Unfortunately, only a piano reduction of the orginal score has survived … but that version has been recorded by the Invencia Piano Duo in Volume 3 of its complete survey of Schmitt’s music for two pianists, just released by NAXOS Grand Piano.

A live performance, also played by the Invencia Piano Duo, is available on YouTube, demonstrating how effective the music is even in the piano version.

Désiré Dondeyne

Désiré Dondeyne (1921-2015)

At least one attempt has been made to re-orchestrate the March: Désiré Dondeyne, a composer and long-time conductor of the Parisian wind ensemble Musique des Gardiens de la Paix, completed the task, and it is this orchestration that has been recorded by Philippe Ferro and L’Orchestre d’Harmonie.

According to Andrey Kasparov of the Invencia Piano Duo, the Dondeyne effort isn’t completely successful. He writes:

“There are some problems with the orchestration. For example, the middle and the bass registers are not very well supported. Schmitt himself would have never have orchestrated the work this way.

When you compare Schmitt’s orchestration of Sélamlik to Dondeyne’s of the March, the difference is evident immediately: beautifully balanced in the Sélamlik versus top-heavy in the March. Still, Dondeyne deserves credit for actually doing it.”

The Philippe Ferro recording of the Dondeyne arrangement has been uploaded to YouTube and can be heard here, as well as a different recording by the Musique Principale de l’Armée de Terre (with interesting historical images of the 163rd Regiment included in the YouTube clip), so listeners can judge for themselves about the quality of the Dondeyne arrangement.

Kasparov and others are mulling the possibility of publishing a new orchestration of the March, which would be welcome.  And beyond that, we can only hope that in the upcoming years, interest in Schmitt’s music will spread beyond just Dionysiaques to encompass all of his other worthy compositions for wind ensemble.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s