Brilliance and Sophistication: Florent Schmitt’s Trois Rapsodies for Two Pianos (1903-04)

One of the most satisfying of Florent Schmitt’s extensive trove of music for piano duet and duo – and the one that is my personal favorite of all of them – is Trois Rapsodies, Op. 53, a work he composed in 1903-4.

Made up of three movements titled Française, Polonaise and Viennoise, it is a work that fully engages the senses on first hearing.

Florent Schmitt: Trois rapsodies for two pianos, Op. 53, score

“Nearly every possible kind of ‘poly’ element – polyphonic, polyrhythmic, poly-thematic”: Florent Schmitt’s Trois rapsodies (1903-4).

That’s not unexpected, considering the “immediate appeal” that music of this kind has on listeners; the rhapsodies of Liszt, Dvořák, Enesco, Ravel and Gershwin are also good cases in point.

What is perhaps more surprising is how interesting and inventive these rhapsodies continue to sound on subsequent hearings.

As it turns out, this isn’t superficial music at all. Instead, it is meaty material that continues to pay rich dividends every time it’s heard. I’ve known this music for more than 40 years, and it never grows old or “routine.”

As the CD booklet notes for one of the Rapsodies recordings puts it:

“The music is saturated with rich harmonies and textures, offering nearly every possible kind of ‘poly’ element – polyphonic, polyrhythmic, poly-thematic – in a rainbow of colors coated with grace and elegance.”

The Canadian pianist Leslie de’Ath contends that Florent Schmitt’s “mastery of the unexpected” is unsurpassed in this particular composition, writing:

“Schmitt’s cornucopia of delicious musical tricks seems always to be just one step ahead of the listener, while at the same time inviting us to savor each unexpected moment.”

The musicologist and librettist Charles Burr described the pieces as “sophisticated national rhapsodies.” He is correct: each of the movements possesses distinct “national” characteristics – yet they are also thoroughly cosmopolitan.

The French novelist and music critic Benoît Duteurtre senses the inspiration of three composers in the music: Chabrier in Française; Chopin in Polonaise; and Johann Strauss Jr. in Viennoise.  Perhaps — but I wouldn’t consider Schmitt to be aping these other composers in any sort of fashion.

Florent Schmitt Trois rapsodies score

Pages from a vintage score to Florent Schmitt’s Trois rapsodies for two pianos (1903-4), published by Durand.

More broadly, the Armenian-American pianist Andrey Kasparov discerns other aspects as well, describing the movements that make up the Trois rapsodies like this:

“[They] are conceived in the grand Romantic style, with the composer taking full advantage of the multilayered textural and coloristic possibilities of two pianos. Despite the intense contrapuntal writing and, at times, complex harmonic language, the work never loses its Gallic charm, lyricism and humor.”

Florent Schmitt Trois rapsodies Casadesus Columbia

First recording: Robert & Gaby Casadesus for Columbia Masterworks (1956).

Fortunately, the music is well-represented on disk today, although it took decades before the first recording would appear.

That premiere recording was made by Columbia Records in 1956 with Robert and Gaby Casadesus – and it would remain the only recorded documentation of this music for nearly 40 years thereafter.

That full-bodied performance is viscerally very exciting, and I think it’s fair to say that no other recording since has conveyed quite the swagger that the Casadesus team delivers.

Gaby Casadesus French pianist

This photo of French pianist Gaby Casadesus (1901-1999) was taken at Maurice Ravel’s home Belvédère in Montfort l’Amaury. Along with her pianist husband Robert, Mme. Casadesus left us scintillating recordings of the piano music of Fauré, Debussy, Ravel and Florent Schmitt, among others.

The Casadesus recording is available to hear on YouTube. If you listen past the somewhat scratchy vinyl and the thin bass response (a defect in the transfer, not in the original Columbia recording which is satisfyingly full-bodied), you’ll discover just how effective the Casadesus interpretation is.

Even better, the recording has finally been reissued on CD mere months ago, after being out of the catalogue for decades.

Florent Schmitt: Trois rapsodies (Sermet + Paik) (Valois)

First stereo recording: Huseyin Sermet and Kun Woo Paik (1992).

In 1992, the first stereo recording of the Trois rapsodies appeared – another highly effective reading by pianists Huseyin Sermet and Kun Woo Paik. Released on the Valois label, this interpretation inhabits a sound-world redolent of the Casadesus performance — but perhaps with a bit more “icy brittleness.”

But you can compare for yourself, thanks to Philippe Louis who has uploaded the Valois performance on one of his worthy YouTube music channels.

The three more recent recordings – two Canadian and one American – are more broadly expansive in their flavor. They are:

Kanazawa-Admony Piano Duo (Tami Kanazawa and Yuval Admony) – Roméo Records (recorded in 2001)

Invencia Piano Duo (Andrey Kasparov and Oksana Lutsyshyn) – NAXOS Grand Piano (recorded in 2010)

Leslie de’Ath and Anya Alexeyev – Dutton Epoch (recorded in 2011)

Having listened to all five of the commercial recordings of the Trois rapsodies, I can confirm that each has its own merits. All of the performances are polished efforts; whichever interpretation one would consider “the best” is purely a matter of personal preference.

Invencia Piano Duo 10th Anniversary Recital

The Invencia Piano Duo’s Tenth Anniversary recital featured the Trois rapsodies and Rhapsodie parisienne of Florent Schmitt (September 2013).

I have also been fortunate to see this music performed in recital — a terrifically exciting performance by the Invencia Piano Duo done in 2013. From this experience, I know first-hand that the rhapsodies make quite an impact when heard live.

It can be safely assumed that the audience at the recital I attended did not know this music at all before hearing it that evening … and yet the response was electric.

Interestingly, there is another two-pianist rhapsody by Florent Schmitt that exists – an unpublished work composed in 1900. Written in much the same vein as the Trois rapsodies, this other one is called Rhapsodie parisienne.

The score was discovered among the composer’s papers at the Bibliothèque National in Paris when Andrey Kasparov and Oksana Lutsyshyn (who make up the Invencia Piano Duo) were doing research as part of their project to record the entire works by Florent Schmitt for piano duet and duo. (Those four CDs were released by NAXOS Grand Piano in 2012 and 2013.)

Thanks to permission granted by Florent Schmitt’s granddaughter, the Rhapsodie Parisienne was able to be recorded.  It appears on the same Invencia Duo CD as the Trois rapsodies, and it proves itself to be every bit as colorful as the other three pieces. An exciting public performance of this rhapsody, played by the Invencia Piano Duo, is also available on YouTube.

Florent Schmitt Rapsodie viennoise

The first of the three rhapsodies orchestrated by Florent Schmitt: Rapsodie viennoise (1911). (Collection Palazzetto Bru Zane)

Schmitt was known to consider the piano to be “a convenient but disappointing substitute for an orchestra” (to quote his own words). So it should come as little surprise that he orchestrated a number of his piano scores for performance in the concert hall. Examples of these works include Soirs, Feuillets de voyage, Mirages, Pupazzi and Reflets d’Allemagne.

Such was the case with the Trois rapsodies also. The first movement to be orchestrated was Rapsodie viennoise, done by Schmitt in 1911. It received its first performance by the Orchestre Lamoureux later that year under the direction of Camille Chevillard (and it was recorded by Albert Wolff with this same orchestra in 1931).  Meanwhile, the first North American performance happened in November 1913, presented by the Philadelphia Orchestra under the direction of Leopold Stokowski.

Paul Paray, French orchestra conductor

Paul Paray (1886-1979) premiered more orchestral works of Florent Schmitt than any other conductor. The Trois rapsodies was premiered by Paray in Paris in 1928, several years after this photo was taken.

Subsequently, Schmitt orchestrated the other two movements as well. The orchestrations were published by Durand, and the full set was premiered by Paul Paray and the Lamoureux Orchestra in 1928.

[According to a report from Andrey Kasparov, when studying the manuscript for the Rhapsodie parisienne he noticed instrument markings made by Schmitt on the score. This leads Kasparov to believe that the composer had intended to orchestrate this work as well.   Why he didn’t – and why the original two-piano version wasn’t published either – remain a mystery.]

Over the years, the Rapsodie viennoise has proved to be the one most often performed in its orchestral garb — being programmed by French conductors such as Jean Martinon and Serge Baudo in the 1950s and 1960s. In one Martinon performance with the Lamoureux Orchestra in 1954, the Le Monde music critic René Dumesnil remarked that the piece ended the concert “like a bouquet of fireworks.”

Timpani Records Complete Albert Wolff recordings with Orchestre Lamoureux

Only orchestral recording (so far): Rapsodie viennoise, with Albert Wolff and l’Orchestre Lamoureux (1931).

Unlike the relatively robust recorded history of the piano version of the Rapsodies, no complete recording of the orchestral version has ever been made. The 1931 Rapsodie viennoise recording is still available today, contained in a large 4-CD set released by Timpani Records that includes all of Albert Wolff’s recordings made with the Lamoureux Orchestra.

Forgotten Records d'Indy Schmitt Roussel WolffFor those who do not wish to invest in a big set such as this, the 1931 Wolff performance has also been issued by Forgotten Records in a single-CD format, along with works by Vincent d’Indy and Albert Roussel.  That CD is available for purchase online and can be ordered here.

Unfortunately both the interpretation and the sound quality of the 1931 Rapsodie viennoise recording are disappointing; the orchestra sounds lumpy and sluggish, and the sound is thin and boxy. It is nice to have it for historical reference – but that’s about all.

Serge Baudo French conductor

Serge Baudo

An alternative to the Wolff/Lamoureux recording exists in the form of a 1964 concert performance done by Serge Baudo with the ORTF Orchestra and broadcast over French National Radio.  Although not much better in terms of sonics, it is a far more vivacious and engaging interpretation.  The Baudo performance has been uploaded to SoundCloud and can be heard here.

Florent Schmitt Trois rapsodies orchestral score

Florent Schmitt completed his orchestration of all three rhapsodies in the 1920s. Curiously, when Durand published the orchestral score the sequence of the movements had been changed, with Rapsodie viennoise now appearing first rather than last. (Collection Palazzetto Bru Zane)

Despite their sonic shortcomings, listening to these orchestral performances makes it clear that this music is well-worthy of resurrection in the modern era. Having paged through the instrumental score, I can report that all of the trademark aspects of Schmitt’s compositional style are present – most particularly the beguiling and highly colorful orchestration in the grandest Rimsky-Korsakov tradition.

Florent Schmitt Rapsodie viennoise score

A vintage copy of the instrumental parts for Florent Schmitt’s orchestrated version of Rapsodie viennoise, which the composer prepared in 1911.

Of the three rhapsodies, Viennoise is the one that gets an occasional airing in concert these days.  It was performed by the late conductor Gianfranco Masini and the Orchestre Philharmonique de Montpellier in July 1991 — a performance which the newspaper Le Monde characterized as follows:

[The piece] begins a bit in the Russian way — Mussorgsky genre — then follows with splendid Viennese waltzes à la Johann Strauss which also resonate with the polyphonic complexity of Richard Strauss, and ends with an astonishing prefiguration of Ravel’s La Valse … This virtuoso, opulent piece puts the musicians of an orchestra to the test — a test that the Monpellier players dispatched with their heads held high.”

Most recently, Jacques Lacombe and the Orchestre Symphonique de Mulhouse performed the Viennoise as part of their 2020 New Year’s Concert program. Moreover, several other conductors I know have considered programming Rapsodie viennoise, but that continues to leave the other two rhapsodies as the odd men out. Here’s hoping that several of Schmitt’s more ardent advocates will redress this situation in the coming years – perhaps conductors Jacques Mercier, JoAnn Falletta, Sascha Goetzel, Fabien Gabel, Jean-Luc TingaudLionel Bringuier or Stéphane Denève will step up to the podium and make the premiere recording. Who’s game for it?

_________________________

The Sony complete Columbia Album Collection CasadesusUpdate (3/5/19):  The Casadesus duo’s premiere recording of Florent Schmitt’s Trois rapsodies has finally been released in CD format featuring a remastering from the 1956 session tapes.

It is part of a collector’s edition set of 65 CDs released by Sony that encompasses all of Robert Casadesus’ recordings for Columbia Masterworks, as well as his Columbia recordings of duo- and triple-pianist works with wife Gaby and son Jean.

The Sony set features original jacket artwork, including the LP release of the Schmitt material (see above) that also contains the piano four-hand suite Une Semaine du petit elfe Ferme-l’oeil.  The set is well-worth acquiring.

2 thoughts on “Brilliance and Sophistication: Florent Schmitt’s Trois Rapsodies for Two Pianos (1903-04)

  1. Pingback: Forgotten Records: Resurrecting noteworthy recordings of Florent Schmitt’s music from the LP era. | Florent Schmitt

  2. Pingback: Triple Threat | Invencia Piano Duo

Leave a Reply